Fate of ‘ugly monstrosity’ in Street to be decided at public inquiry just after Easter
A decision on the future of the Crispin Shopping Centre in Street will be made at a public inquiry just after Easter, following months of debate over plans to demolish the site and build a retirement complex in its place.
The Crispin Centre, described by some as an "ugly monstrosity", has been at the centre of controversy since developer Churchill Retirement Living submitted proposals to replace it with a new housing scheme for older people.
The plans would see the existing precinct replaced with a three-storey block of 45 retirement apartments and 11 retirement cottages, along with communal lounges, landscaped gardens, and parking. While Churchill argues the scheme would bring much-needed housing to a central and accessible location, opponents have raised concerns about the design, the lack of parking, and the potential impact on nearby heritage assets.
Somerset Council's Planning Committee East unanimously refused the application in July 2024, citing issues around scale, layout, infrastructure, and a lack of affordable housing provision. Concerns were also raised about phosphate mitigation, vehicle access, and how the development could affect the setting of Crispin Hall and the surrounding conservation area.
Churchill has appealed the decision, describing the refusal as "extremely disappointing". A spokesperson said the development would reduce loneliness among older residents, support independent living, and help release under-occupied family homes back into the local market.
The Planning Inspectorate has now confirmed a public inquiry will begin at 10am on Tuesday 23 April, held at Somerset Council's offices on Cannards Grave Road in Shepton Mallet. An inspector appointed by the Secretary of State will consider the appeal over five days.
The Crispin Centre has been a familiar part of Street's High Street since the late 1970s but has declined in recent years, particularly following the closure of Tesco Metro. The site is one of nine locations identified for new housing in the council's revised Mendip Local Plan.
The inquiry is open to the public, and those wishing to speak will need to contact Somerset Council's Planning-East Team in advance.
The appeal is listed under reference APP/E3335/W/24/3356026, and all related documents can be viewed on the Somerset Council website.
Share:
